Sinéad Kearns, co-owner of Herman White Properties, meets the housing crisis at the point where people have to make decisions. For many, property is not about timing. It is about the moment life forces a move, after a bereavement, a separation, a growing family, or when a house no longer fits the person living in it.
Listen too the radio show here (Jan19)
Her route into real estate was direct. “I basically fell into the business. I was unemployed, looking for work, and I ended up coming into admin in an auctioneers in Rathnew, so I started off on reception there,” she said. “I got interested because it was around the same time that I was buying my own home. I could see it from both sides.”
That first role became a career. “Over time, they approached me about becoming a qualified agent, and they helped me get onto a course. From then on, I’ve been qualified,” she said. “I’ve worked with Herman White since 2009.”
Kearns is careful to explain how regulated the industry now is, because she believes the public often underestimates the oversight. “The PSRA is our licensing body,” she said. “To be able to be a full active auctioneer or estate agent, you have to be licensed under an operating company, and you have to have a certain level of qualifications.” She began before licensing was introduced, and described the adjustment as standards were formalised and enforced.
The glamour associated with real estate has little to do with her work. Asked about the Netflix version, she said, “I don’t think I’d have lasted in the business if I had to wear the heels that they wear, because my ankles could not take it.”
For Kearns, the work is personal. “It’s extremely personal,” she said. “Glamour is great, but glamour will only get you so far when you’re selling a property, or you’re asking somebody to have confidence in you when you’re managing their property. You have to be genuine. That’s what people trust.”
She is equally clear about how most people behave in the market. They are not trading housing like an asset. “The majority of people, unless it is your full time business, as a developer or you’re flipping houses, that’s when market trends would dictate what you do,” she said. “But everyday Joe Soap is not watching trends. If you have a deceased family member and you have to sell, you sell. The market is the market at the time. There’s always going to be a buyer. It’s just a matter of what the price is going to be.”
Where the system is failing most sharply, she said, is at the first step. “It’s so hard for people now, the prices are super inflated the way it is at the moment,” she said. “To ask somebody younger, renting and paying a really high rent, to save 30, 40, 50,000 as a deposit is very hard. For many, the bank of mum and dad is what makes it possible.”
Kearns expects pressure to force some rebalancing, but she does not talk in crash language. “There has to be some sort of a correction within the market, which I think will come,” she said. “It’s not going to be a crash, I don’t think, but there will have to be some sort of a levelling of affordability. The only way that can happen is new stock.”
She also warned against assuming that a cheaper house is automatically a cheaper outcome. Building and renovation costs have risen, and she sees buyers underestimating the final bill once trades, materials and timelines are added up.
For people trying to buy, her advice is to stay steady in a process that can be bruising. “It’s not to be worried about the first pushback,” she said. “If you put in your offer and it’s not accepted, don’t be afraid to let the offer sit and tell the agent that you’re still interested.” Where a buyer has room to move, she believes clarity matters. “If you have the means to put up your offer, do it,” she said. “If you can’t, say, that’s exactly where I’m at, I can’t go any further than that.”
She described it as a relationship business, not a one-off confrontation. “Nine times out of 10, the agent will say, you may not be successful this time,” she said. “But we have this property coming up, we’ll keep you in mind for anything else. It’s about working up a relationship as well.”
Kearns urged people to ask for advice earlier and to treat local agents as a source of information, not an obstacle. “Don’t be afraid to ring an estate agent and ask for advice,” she said. “We have absolutely no issue about giving out advice. The days of us holding cards close to our chest, that’s gone. It’s so regulated that it’s impossible not to do it the right way.”
Her client base reflects pressure across the market. “We have a mixed board of people,” she said. “We have a lot of people downsizing, and we have accidental landlords.”
The accidental landlord, as she describes it, is not an investor. “Say a family member dies, they weren’t in a position to sell the property at that time, they decide to rent it out and then sell it further down the line,” she said. “So they’re an accidental landlord. It’s not their business.”
Downsizing is where housing policy meets lived reality. People want to stay close to family, friends and services, but the supply of smaller homes is limited, pushing many towards apartments. “They’re going into apartment living when they’re not used to apartment living, and that is a big adjustment,” she said. “You have people on either side of you, and most likely people above and below you as well.”
She spoke positively about alternative models that offer independence with community, including retirement villages. “I love the idea of the retirement communities that they have in America,” she said. “I think it’s something that should come in more here.” But she also pointed to a cultural constraint. “We’re not a culture of renters, we’re a culture of owners,” she said. “So when it comes to a retirement village of that kind, unless you can own the house, people don’t tend to gravitate towards that.”
Kearns also sees intergenerational living becoming more common, not as a lifestyle trend but as a consequence of scarcity. “It’s something that I could possibly see coming back in again because of the lack of housing,” she said. “They have no choice. They cannot move out and in order for everyone to save on their money, it makes sense to stay together.” For any shared arrangement, her guidance is plain. “Before you sign anything or you enter it, sit down and have an open and frank conversation about the parameters,” she said. “If everybody’s on the same page from the start, it cuts out a lot of that annoyance.”
The conversation also touched on the way housing becomes more fraught during relationship breakdowns, particularly where children are involved. She described the additional stress that property introduces to separation, and noted that her firm can be involved in court work as expert witnesses.
She also mentioned the rise of garden rooms and cabins, partly driven by adult children staying longer at home, and partly by the search for workable space. On planning, her caution was practical. “It’s something that you’d have to look into, depending on the type of structure it is, whether you’d need planning permission or retention,” she said. “But the garden rooms and the log cabins are very desirable at the moment. If you do decide to sell the house, it’s a really great feature of the house.”
What distinguishes Herman White, however, is the link with Herman’s Auctions on the same site in Rathnew, which allows a start-to-finish service when a family member dies. “If you have a family member who sadly passes, a lot of people have no idea where to begin,” she said. “Probate is something everybody has heard of, but has no idea what it’s about or what it does.”
The goal is to reduce handovers at a moment when people are overwhelmed. “We can do the probate valuation for both the house and the contents,” she said. “We can advise on what contents can be sold, and if there’s contents that can’t be sold, we can get in touch with removers.” And it continues through to sale. “We can go from absolute start to finish with the whole service,” she said. “It takes that strain off because you’re dealing with the one person for the whole thing.”
Even the contents of a house can carry unexpected value. “We call it the big brown furniture, your big brown wooden wardrobe that you’d have seen in your granny’s house,” she said. “For a while, it wasn’t saleable. Now, the upcycle market has come along, so people are buying that, upcycling it, and reselling it.” Her point is that families can discard value through uncertainty.
On policy, her message is consistent: legislation is lagging the problem, and the response is reactive. “They need to stop being reactive and be proactive,” she said. “By the time it’s in and it’s passed, the trend has moved on. The issue has moved on, and it’s bigger than the legislation is providing for.”
Her position on supply is blunt, then qualified. “They need to provide more housing,” she said. “More stock is the only thing that’s going to alleviate the housing crisis.” The condition is competence. “Don’t just give out planning permissions like it had been done in the past. It has to be done properly, but the only way is more stock.” And she does not believe it can be designed solely at a remove. “They can’t do it from a desk,” she said. “They have to get out into the community and talk to the community as well. They need to get into the community and see what the community itself needs. That’s the only sustainable way.”
